-
Retrospective “Clarification” and the Limits of Taxing Power: Karnataka High Court’s Decision in Jindal Thermal Power
1. Why the ruling mattersThe Karnataka High Court’s judgment dated August 6, 2026, in Jindal Thermal Power Company Limited, earlier known as Jindal Tractebel Power Company Ltd., v. Deputy Commissioner...
-
Tax Treatment of Pre-Exercise ESOP Liquidity: Salary Perquisite or Capital Gains?
1. Why pre-exercise ESOP monetisation creates a tax problemEmployee Stock Option Plans, commonly known as ESOPs, are now a regular feature of compensation structures in India as well as in multination...
-
Section 14A of the Income-tax Act: A Case for Reviewing Revenue Efficacy and Curtailing Disproportionate Litigation
Background and Legislative History of Section 14ASection 14A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, was inserted via Clause 11 of the Finance Act, 2001, with retrospective effect from 1 April 1962. The provisio...
-
Section 271(1)(c) Penalty Notice Must Identify the Specific Limb Charged — Delhi High Court in Vitasta Estates
Background and SignificanceThe Delhi High Court, in Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi-7 v. Vitasta Estates Pvt. Ltd. — (2026) TaxCorp(LJ) 38566 (HC-DELHI) — Delhi High Court, has reaffirmed...
-
Preference Bonus Shares to Equity Shareholders: Corporate Structuring and Tax Consequences
1. Why the Siyaram arrangement is noteworthyA company with large accumulated reserves generally has a few familiar choices: declare dividend, issue equity bonus shares, undertake buy-back, or retain t...
-
Will as an Estate Planning Tool: Purpose, Drafting, Mutual Wills and Probate Issues
1. Meaning and practical relevance of a WillA Will is a written legal expression of a person’s intention regarding the manner in which his or her property should be dealt with after death. The person...
-
Section 56 and Section 64: Does Tax-Free Gift Treatment Override Clubbing?
The taxation of gifts in India has moved through two distinct legislative phases. Earlier, gifts were taxed under the Gift-tax Act in the hands of the donor. After the Gift-tax Act was abolished in 19...
-
JAO or FAO in Reassessment Proceedings: Section 147A and the Constitutional Limits of Retrospective Clarification
1. The controversy in briefThe procedural dispute around reassessment notices under the Income-tax Act, 1961 has largely centred on one question: when action is taken under section 148 or section 148A...
-
FAST Scheme 2026: A One-Time Window for Small Taxpayers to Regularise Undisclosed Foreign Assets
Indian tax residents are required to be transparent about assets, financial interests, income and beneficial ownership held outside India. This disclosure is made through Schedule FA in Income-tax Ret...
-
HUF PAN Misquoted in Property Purchase Deed: Lessons from ITAT Chennai Ruling on Section 56 Addition
Background and Case ReferenceA recent ruling by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Chennai, offers instructive lessons for both taxpayers and tax authorities regarding the consequences of quoting a Hi...
-
Section 10(14)(i) and Rule 2BB: Legal Framework, Conditions and Consequences of Unsupported Refund Claims for AY 2026-27
Background and ContextDuring the return filing season for Assessment Year 2026-27, Section 10(14)(i) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 has become one of the most widely — and often incorrectly — invoked pro...
-
Capital Gains as “Income”: Recasting the Navinchandra Mafatlal Rule on the Breadth of Legislative Entries
1. The central holdingIn Navinchandra Mafatlal v. Commissioner of Income-tax, AIR 1955 SC 58, the Supreme Court settled an important constitutional question: the word “income” in Entry 54 of List I of...
-
Taxation and Other Laws (Amendment) Act, 2026: Using Tax Certainty to Attract Capital, Technology and Global Business Functions
1. Introduction: A Tax Law with a Wider Economic PurposeThe Taxation and Other Laws (Amendment) Act, 2026, referred to as “TOLA 2026”, is not merely a set of technical amendments to the Income-tax Act...
-
Unexercised ESOPs: When Does Tax Law Step In?
1. The issue: ESOPs do not always follow the standard pathEmployee stock options, commonly referred to as ESOPs or stock options, are not simple tax instruments. In their usual form, they pass through...
-
Optional Convertibles in India: Accounting, Company Law, FEMA and Tax Treatment of OCPS and OCDs
1. Why optional convertibles require separate analysisOptionally Convertible Preference Shares (“OCPS”) and Optionally Convertible Debentures (“OCDs”) are frequently used in private equity, venture ca...
-
Deeming in Tax Law: The Reach and Restraint of a Statutory Fiction
1. Deeming as a legislative deviceThe expression “deemed” is one of the most powerful drafting tools in legislation. It allows the legislature to direct that, for the purposes of a statute, a thing sh...
-
Foreign ESOPs and Indian Return Filing: Why Vested Stock Options May Need Schedule FA Reporting and How FAST-DS 2026 Can Help
Indian employees working for subsidiaries of multinational groups often receive stock options from the foreign parent company. These options may vest over time, but the employee may not immediately ex...
-
Section 264 and the Shrinking Space for Substantive Tax Relief: Reading Two Supreme Court Outcomes Together
Section 264 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 is meant to function as a taxpayer-friendly revisional remedy. It enables the Principal Commissioner of Income-tax or Commissioner to revise an order passed by...
-
Tax Character of Cash Received for Vested but Unexercised ESOPs
1. The issue: when an ESOP is cashed out before exerciseEmployee stock options are often taxed on the assumption that the employee will move through the usual sequence of grant, vesting, exercise, all...
-
Capital Gains on Sale of Residential Property after 23 July 2024: Computation, Reinvestment and Proof
1. Why ordinary property sales have become more complexThe Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024 changed the capital-gains calculation for land and buildings. For transfers taking place on or after 23 July 2024,...